Veg protein sources

Can Vegetarians Get Enough Protein? A Simple Guide with a Veg Protein Plate

Can I Get Enough Protein Without Eating Non-Veg?

By Dr S. Nishanth | MD, DNB (General Medicine), MRCP (UK), FNB (Critical Care), EDIC, FECMO | Head, Department of Critical Care Medicine, SKS Hospital and Post Graduate Medical Institute, Salem | Reg.no 93312

Short answer

Yes. A well-planned vegetarian diet can meet your daily protein needs. Dal and other pulses, milk and curd, paneer, soya, peanuts and whole grains together supply enough protein for most healthy adults. What matters is how much of these foods you eat every day, and in what variety, not whether your plate is vegetarian or non-vegetarian.

Q1. How much protein does an adult need every day?

A healthy adult needs about 0.83 g of protein per kg of body weight per day, according to the ICMR-NIN Nutrient Requirements for Indians. For a 65 kg man this is about 54 g a day, and for a 55 kg woman about 46 g a day.

Needs are higher in some situations. The ICMR-NIN Dietary Guidelines for Indians 2024 state that more protein is required by growing children, adolescents, pregnant women, and during infections, illness and physical stress. In pregnancy, an extra 8 g a day is advised in the second trimester and 18 g in the third trimester. During the first six months of breastfeeding, an extra 13.6 g a day is advised.

Q2. Don’t non-veg foods have far more protein than vegetarian foods?

Not as much as people think. Per 100 g of raw food, the ICMR-NIN guidelines list the average protein content as follows:

Food group (per 100 g, raw)

Protein (g)

Pulses

22.8

Milk products (group average)

21.6

Meat and poultry

20.8

Fish and seafood

18.4

Nuts

17.5

Egg

13.3

Cereals

9.3

Milk (per 100 ml)

3.1

Two points help in reading this table honestly. First, dry pulses are being compared with raw meat. Once dal is cooked it absorbs water, so one katori of cooked dal gives about 7 g of protein, not 23 g. Second, animal proteins are of higher quality because they provide all the essential amino acids in the right proportions, while individual plant proteins are low in some of them. This gap can be closed by combining foods, as explained in Q4.

The bigger problem in India is the balance of the plate. The ICMR-NIN guidelines report that cereals supply 50% to 70% of daily energy, while pulses, meat, poultry and fish together supply only 6% to 9%, against a recommended level of about 14%. In other words, many people, vegetarian or not, eat too much cereal and too little dal.

Q3. Which vegetarian foods are rich in protein?

The table below gives approximate values. Exact figures vary with brand, variety and cooking method.

Food

Typical serving

Approx. protein per serving

Approx. per 100 g (raw/dry unless stated)

Soya chunks

25 g dry

~13 g

~52 g (check the pack label)

Paneer

50 g

~9 g

~18 g

Peanuts

30 g

~8 g

~26 g

Dal (moong, masoor, toor), cooked

1 katori (from about 30 g dry)

~7 g

~22 to 24 g

Rajma or chole, cooked

1 katori (from about 30 g dry)

~6 to 7 g

~23 g (rajma), ~19 g (kabuli chana)

Milk

1 glass (200 ml)

~6 g

~3.1 g per 100 ml

Moong sprouts

1 cup (100 g)

~4 g

~3 to 4 g

Curd

1 katori (100 g)

~3 g

~3 g

Wheat roti

1 medium

~3 g

cereals average ~9 g

Q4. Is plant protein “incomplete”? Do I need to combine foods?

Individually, most plant foods are low in one or more essential amino acids. The ICMR-NIN guidelines point out that a combination of cereals, millets and pulses provides most of the amino acids, because they complement each other, giving good quality protein. The guidelines mention a cereal to pulse ratio of about 3:1 for this purpose.

This is why traditional Indian combinations work well: dal with roti or rice, khichdi, rajma with rice, idli with sambar, and ragi or millet preparations with dal. Adding milk, curd, paneer or nuts improves the protein quality further.

Q5. What does a vegetarian protein plate look like?

The ICMR-NIN “My Plate for the Day” recommends that vegetables, fruits, green leafy vegetables, roots and tubers form about half of the plate. The rest is made up of cereals and millets, pulses, nuts and seeds, and milk or curd.

For a 2,000 kcal vegetarian diet, the guidelines suggest roughly 250 g cereals and millets, 85 g pulses, 300 ml milk or curd, 400 g vegetables including green leafy vegetables, 100 g fruits, 35 g nuts and seeds, and 27 g oil or fat. This provides about 72 g of protein a day.

A simple sample day, using the approximate values above:

Meal

What is on the plate

Approx. protein

Breakfast

1 glass milk + 1 cup moong sprouts

~10 g

Mid-morning

Roasted peanuts (30 g)

~8 g

Lunch

2 rotis + 1 katori dal + 1 katori curd

~16 g

Dinner

2 rotis + paneer (50 g) + 1 katori rajma

~22 g

Total

 

About 56 g, plus a few grams from vegetables

This is a sample, not a prescription. Your own needs depend on your body weight, age, activity and health conditions.

Q6. Do I need protein powders or supplements?

For most healthy people, no. The ICMR-NIN Dietary Guidelines for Indians 2024 advise getting good quality protein and essential amino acids through an appropriate combination of foods, and avoiding protein supplements to build muscle mass. Media reports on the guidelines note that prolonged use of large amounts of protein powders or protein concentrates has been associated with bone mineral loss and kidney damage, and that going above about 1.6 g per kg a day gives no added muscle gain with resistance training.

Supplements may have a place when a doctor or dietitian identifies a specific need, for example during recovery from a serious illness. That decision should be individual.

Q7. What else should vegetarians watch for?

The ICMR-NIN guidelines list vitamin B12 and long-chain omega-3 fatty acids as nutrients of concern for vegetarians. Milk contains only a small amount of vitamin B12. Flax seeds, chia seeds, walnuts and green leafy vegetables are suggested as omega-3 sources. If you follow a vegetarian diet, ask your doctor whether your vitamin B12 level should be checked.

Q8. When should I see a doctor?

Please speak to a doctor before changing your protein intake if you have kidney disease, liver disease or diabetes with kidney involvement, or if you are on dialysis, because protein needs in these conditions are individualised. Please also consult a doctor if you are pregnant, are caring for a child who is not growing well, or are an older adult with unintended weight loss or muscle weakness. Persistent tiredness, swelling of the feet or slow wound healing also deserve a medical check-up rather than self-treatment.

Key takeaways

  • Vegetarian diets can meet protein needs when pulses, milk or curd, paneer, soya, nuts and whole grains are eaten daily.
  • The common gap is too much cereal and too little dal, in vegetarians and non-vegetarians alike.
  • Combine cereals with pulses, and add curd, milk or paneer, for better protein quality.
  • Fill half your plate with vegetables and fruits.
  • Choose food first. Avoid protein powders unless advised by your doctor.

Consult Dr S. Nishanth, Internal Medicine specialist and Intensivist, at SKS Hospital and Post Graduate Medical Institute, Salem. Website: www.drsnishanth.com | Instagram: dr_s.nishanth

This article is for general public education and does not replace personal medical advice.

References

  1. ICMR-National Institute of Nutrition. Dietary Guidelines for Indians 2024. Hyderabad: ICMR-NIN; 2024 (Tables 1.1 to 1.3, Table 1.2a, Guidelines 1 and 2, and the Current Diet and Nutrition Scenario section). https://www.nin.res.in/dietaryguidelines/pdfjs/locale/DGI24thJune2024fin.pdf
  2. Longvah T, Ananthan R, Bhaskarachary K, Venkaiah K. Indian Food Composition Tables 2017. Hyderabad: ICMR-National Institute of Nutrition; 2017.
  3. ICMR-National Institute of Nutrition. Nutrient Requirements for Indians 2020 (updated 2023). Hyderabad: ICMR-NIN.
  4. The South First. ICMR releases Dietary Guidelines for Indians after 13 years, says no to protein supplements. 10 May 2024. https://thesouthfirst.com/news/icmr-releases-dietary-guidelines-for-indians-after-13-years-says-no-to-protein-supplements

Leave A Comment

All fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required

Call Us